This early design image for 222 Corfield St. South shows what the supportive housing building could look like. — Courtesy BC Housing

Petitioners must re-submit in Parksville supportive housing bylaw case

Lawyer said clients hope for ‘positive resolution’ out of court

With a judge’s decision to allow BC Housing to respond to the petition against the rezoning for Parksville’s 222 Corfield supportive housing project, the court case is back to square one.

According to Supreme Court Justice Robin A. Baird, in his decision allowing BC Housing and the Provincial Rental Housing Corporation to become respondents on Dec. 27, the petitioners must re-file their petition (which questions the legality of the city’s rezoning bylaw process), allowing BC Housing 21 days to respond.

The petitioners’ lawyer, however, said his clients hope the parties can come to a resolution outside of court. The City of Parksville and the petitioners’ first attempt at such a deal was described as “decidedly offside” by Baird.

“We respect the judge’s opinion,” said the petitioners’ lawyer, Mark Sager, referring to Baird’s decision to make BC Housing a respondent.

“Our clients were surprised that BC Housing wanted to continue, because there’s been some very productive discussions going on between all the different parties to try and come up with a win-win for the whole community, for everybody, for BC Housing, for citizens of Parksville, for the person building the seniors housing next door to this proposed facility,” he said.

In Baird’s reasoning for making BC Housing a respondent to the petition, he said “Such an approach, on the facts as I appreciate them, would have been decidedly offside. The issues raised in the petition must be fully and publicly aired.

“The applicants (BC Housing and the Provincial Rental Housing Corporation) are in a good position to defend the bylaw if the city is no longer willing to do it. I see no reason why they should not, in the midst of their efforts, make full and productive use of the evidence already filed by city employees to the effect that there was no procedural irregularity or unfairness involved in the enactment of the amending bylaw.”

Meanwhile, Sager emphasized that he and his clients hope for a “positive resolution” out of court.

“In the spirit of good faith, the parties are trying to resolve their differences and create a win,” said Sager. “If they can’t, then it’s back to the courts and the chips will fall where they may there. Hopefully that doesn’t need to happen.”

In Baird’s background on the case, he notes how the city took a “firm position in defence of the validity of the amending bylaw,” describing “in considerable detail the city’s fulfilment of all legally binding notice and procedural requirements before and during the public meeting.”

The firm position changed to “unexplained capitulation” shortly after, with a new council at the city’s helm.

“They (the city) are prepared to consent to an order quashing the amending bylaw. They have not given reasons for this decision. Importantly, however, the city has never conceded there was anything improper or defective in the process leading to the amending bylaw’s adoption and enactment.”

While the court case questions only the legality of the city’s bylaw amendment process (before and during its public hearing) and not the Corfield project itself, Sager said: “everybody recognizes the value and the need of more affordable housing for people in need… I think it’s fair to say everybody respects that desire, and it’s simply a matter of having facilities side-by-side that are compatible in nature and don’t cause unnecessary problems for anybody.”

Just Posted

Parksville seniors getting stronger with age

Weightlifting couple qualify to compete at Worlds Masters in Montreal in August

Camera captures cougar lurking in Parksville’s Foster Park neighbourhood

Resident shared photo to alert others to big cat’s presence

RDN tipping fees set to go up in July

The Regional District of Nanaimo is set to increase tipping fees at… Continue reading

VIDEO: RCMP ask kids to help name soon-to-be police dogs

13 German shepherd puppies will be born this year

Watchdog called after man who yelled racial slurs at B.C. vigil hurt during arrest

BC RCMP say man was ‘acting suspiciously’ at prayer vigil for victims of New Zealand mosque shootings

NDP’s Jagmeet Singh steps into the House of Commons, making history

Burnaby South MP becomes first visible minority to lead a federal party in the House of Commons

Reeling Port Alice about to lose its only bank

Scotiabank branch closure follows latest mill setback, bad for business and the elderly

Simard guilty in Vancouver Island double murder

Convicted of two counts of second-degree murder in 2016 killing of Courtenay couple

Crab poaching under cover of darkness earns 10-year commercial fishing ban, vessel seizure

A Cape Mudge resident involved in poaching dungeness crabs in Vancouver Harbour… Continue reading

‘Considerably large’ tractor tire fell and killed 3-year-old girl on B.C. farm

Delta’s deputy fire chief said crews tried to helicopter girl out after a tractor tire leaning against a barn fell onto her

Nearly 40% of British Columbians not taking their medications correctly: poll

Introduction of legal cannabis could cause more issues for drug interactions

Mining company fined $70,000 after two workers killed in B.C. truck crash

Broda Construction pleaded guilty to failing to provide safe workplace at Cranbrook rock quarry

Most Read