EDITORIAL: B.C. Premier John Horgan’s Kinder Morgan stance is either brilliant, stupid or cynical

The more and more ballistic the hyperbole from Alberta and other Kinder Morgan pipeline expansion supporters gets, the calmer and more reasoned B.C. Premier John Horgan seems.

The man is either wiley like a coyote or as oblivious as a fencepost.

That’s because – depending on your point of view – the B.C. government’s steadfast opposition to the pipeline is either a simple assertion of the province’s right to protect its environment or it’s a suicidal attempt to destroy the provincial economy and rip the nation asunder!

Related: B.C. premier denies crisis, says one investment doesn’t make an economy

The spat between Horgan’s NDP government and the NDP government of Alberta Premier Rachel Notley is approaching hysterical levels — both on the east side of the Canadian Rockies and the right side of the B.C. Legislature. Horgan has taken to responding to the hysteria with calm.

Horgan implied on Monday that the Notley government and B.C. opposition Liberals are overstating the effect of his government’s stance when he said, “One investment project does not an economy make.”

It’s either a deliberate attempt to be seen as the firm but reasonable statesman or it simply is his personality. But it could also be a deliberate attempt to manage the dispute in a way that makes his government come out smelling like roses. Given the B.C. NDP’s traditional power base (labour, soft environmentalists and other ideological leftists), opposition to the expansion of the Kinder Morgan Pipeline can only be a good thing for them politically.

It’s less clear what the “traditional NDP power base” consists of in Alberta. But we digress.

Horgan has said his government is leaving it up to the courts to rule whether B.C. has the power to stop the pipeline expansion. That’s a tactic that can only leave him smelling like roses with his supporters. The court challenge could likely be window dressing. The province launched it knowing it couldn’t win but then it could say, “Look, we did everything we could, but the courts told us we don’t have the authority to do this” and then wash its hands of the pipeline proceeding, securing the fabric of the nation and staving off the destruction of the provincial economy.

Because that’s the credo of B.C.’s opponents right now. Horgan is threatening national unity, usurping the rule of law and in danger of throwing project approval processes into irrelevancy with his ‘reckless approach’ to this issue.

On the other hand, maybe Horgan stands defiant in steadfast defence of B.C.’s coastal environment and its people. At least, until he’s removed from the path of the pipeline by a court ruling and left to say, “We did what we could.”

— Black Press

Just Posted

Gr. 7s learn about digital safety, health, consent at con in Parksville

SD69 hosts first Health and Wellness Conference for students headed to high school

Qualicum Beach east village plans take shape

Staff moving forward with east village concept

Three-for-one at Parksville studio for tour

Local artists participating in Central Island Studio Tour May 26-27

Pole dancers bring disco theme for second Errington hall event

Island Talent Pole Fitness show to include national champs on June 2

Annual pickleball tournament fills up quickly

Two-day event to take place indoors at Oceanside Place May 24-25

VIDEO: Sharks’ jaws too sharp for Whalers

First junior B lacrosse team delights local fans with 13-3 win

Early learning programs for Indigeous kids get $30M boost

B.C. government to help expand Aboriginal Head Start Association programs with three-year funding

Ferry sailing cancelled after ship’s second officer falls ill

Coastal Inspiration’s 8:15 p.m. sailing to Nanaimo on Tuesday cancelled, passengers to be compensated

B.C. man recounts intense rescue of couple caught in mudslide

Something told Dan Anderson to go back to the scene of a major mudslide on the long weekend.

The priciest home for sale in Canada: A $38M Vancouver penthouse

Canada’s luxury real estate: The top 10 most expensive properties for sale right now

9 temperature records broken across B.C. as warm weather continues

Clearwater, Golden, Williams Lake, Malahat a few of the cities that broke records Wednesday

COLUMN: Stanley Cup final prediction

Upstart Vegas Golden Knights clash with Washington Capitals

Vancouver Island wildfire burning near Campbell River coal mine

The fire is suspected to be human caused at this time

Big brew tanks headed for Chilliwack wrapped to look like beer cans

Snap a #beertanks selfie if you see massive tanks en route to Chilliwack

Most Read