Gracious critique

I was surprised at the vitriolic tone of Gerald Marantz’ letter to the editor ‘Lunney’s beliefs are not ours’

I was surprised at the vitriolic tone of Gerald Marantz’ letter to the editor ‘Lunney’s beliefs are not ours’ (The NEWS, March 19).

While I believe in freedom of expression and freedom of speech, and many of the other freedoms that Canadians enjoy, surely, as a matter of courtesy, when making statements such as Marantz made, they should be backed up with supporting facts.

For example: When did James Lunney lie about his religious beliefs to his constituency and how they influence his political decisions? And as for the statement that “His delusional and supernatural hallucinations were a blatant abrogation of his duty to uphold our Charter of Rights and are insulting to this great nation’s ideals,” I ask the question: because a person is influenced by their religious beliefs does this mean that they are delusional and suffering from supernatural hallucinations, and as a consequence fail to uphold the Charter of Rights and Freedoms?

In our confused and dangerous world I am thankful that Lunney has the courage to apply his religious beliefs to his political life. He has not shelved what he believes in order to court favour with anyone. It is not always easy or acceptable to stand for Christian beliefs and principles and I applaud anyone who, often at personal cost, is prepared to be true to their well-thought-out and reasoned faith.

I am also reminded that the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms does state that everyone has freedom of conscience and religion, and freedom of thought, belief, opinion and expression. The Charter also refers to the fact that hate is not acceptable.

I do not expect Marantz, or anyone else to think or believe as I do, or as Lunney does, but when we do disagree let us express our differences in a manner that is gracious and worthy of respect.

Geoffrey DixonParksville

Just Posted

Celebration of life announced for Parksville man who died following reported hit and run

Investigation still underway following death of Spencer Alexander Moore

Halloween festivities abound in Parksville Qualicum Beach area

From aerial shows to trick or treating, there’s plenty of event options for all ages

Mushroom festival returns to Coombs

Displays, talks, mushroom identification and more

ELECTION 2019: NDP’s Gord Johns re-elected in Courtenay-Alberni

Conservative Byron Horner finishes second, with Green Party’s Sean Wood third

VIDEO: Is the stethoscope dying? High-tech options pose threat

World-renowned cardiologist believes the device is just a pair of ‘rubber tubes’

85-year-old woman perishes in house fire in Cumberland Wednesday

Police and fire personnel were called to the scene of a fire… Continue reading

‘Cartoony’ mushrooms popping up across Vancouver Island are highly poisonous

Fly Agaric mushrooms can cause hallucinations, gastrointestinal pain and death

Beers on the job, smacking crotches: 10 police misconduct probes in B.C.

Recent report by the Office of the Police Complaint Commissioner highlights a number of investigations

Seizure of cannabis edibles, including mac-and-cheese, prompt warning from B.C. RCMP

Potato chips, cheesecake and candy infused with cannabis also seized back in August

B.C. parents sue city and province in 12-year-old daughter’s drowning at lake

Beverly Park drowned at Rotary Lake in Dawson Creek in August 2016

Island mom warning others as suspicious powder found in mail

“I was very uneasy … it could be coffee whitener or it could be something else in the bag.”

VIDEO: Chill with polar bears through an Arctic live cam

Cam reopens just ahead of Polar Bear Week

Most Read