LETTER: Canadian ‘speculators’ net benefit to B.C. economy

Recently, the B.C. Minister of Finance previewed two budget proposals ostensibly designed to address the cost of owning or renting residential property in British Columbia. The stated targets were Canadians officially resident in other provinces who own vacation homes in B.C., and “foreigners” who live abroad for most of the year whose properties in B.C. stand empty for most of the year. These proposals created a storm of protest from a wide range of stakeholders.

The stakeholders directly affected include: both resident and non-resident owners, people looking for affordable housing, realtors, tradesmen who build and renovate homes, and people providing a broad range of retail products and services. Directly or indirectly, we are all affected.

In my opinion, these proposals will not only fail to achieve their stated purposes, they are likely to have negative consequences that far outweigh whatever benefit was sought. The market is both dynamic and sophisticated, making it difficult to predict the outcomes of changes in government policy. However, here are some probably consequences:

It will discourage investment in new housing by both B.C. residents and those from neighbouring provinces; will make rental properties scarcer and more expensive; will have a negative impact on the local economy, including job losses in services and construction; will lower the revenue the governments will receive from income, sales and municipal taxation; and will exacerbate tensions between provinces caused by pre-existing conflicts over cross-border pipelines and other matters. It will dash the hopes and dreams of many people who in good faith decided to live, at least part-time, in B.C.

The rhetoric justifying these proposals paints a largely false picture of new residents to B.C. They are portrayed as “speculators” taking advantage of rising property values to “gouge” long-term residents. In reality, our temporary visitors from other provinces provide a net financial benefit to the provincial treasury. There are elements of nativism in that rhetoric similar to what is emerging in political discourse in the U.S. and parts of Europe.

It makes little sense to impose a solution designed to address Vancouver’s housing problems. The Comox Regional District is exluded despite having similar demographics to Parksville Qualicum Beach and the Okanagan. The main difference is the MLA for Comox is a member of the government party.

Dr. John Hogarth


Just Posted

Unique type of rock show at Parksville beach

WATCH: Rock art from youngsters and adults alike on display

Short list for new gnome home includes Parksville, Coombs

Five potential locations have been chosen by Howard’s owners who will decide Tuesday

Parksville’s mystery cowboy revealed

Kevin Gourlay’s horse garners attention for being ‘parked’ outside a liquor store

Qualicum man sentenced for tying up, robbing another man

Gabriel Stephen Nelson robbed and assaulted travelling businessman in 2017

Truck driver in fatal Broncos crash sentenced to eight years

Judge Inez Cardinal told court in Melfort, Sask., that Sidhu’s remorse and guilty plea were mitigating factors

Fierce feline spotted as ‘aggressor’ in face off with coyote in B.C. backyard

North Vancouver resident Norm Lee captures orange cat versus coyote in backyard showdown

Wilson-Raybould to reveal more details, documents on SNC-Lavalin affair

Former attorney general has written to the House of Commons justice committee

Anti-discrimination group wants to map offenders with cross-Canada hate atlas

Morgane Oger Foundation issues call for volunteers to help build Canadian Atlas of Populist Extremism

Dump truck driver hurt after highway crash on Vancouver Island

One man airlifted to hospital after collision between dump truck and pickup Friday in Ladysmith

Kater to launch ridesharing service in Vancouver by end of month

The Surrey-based company got its permits from the Vancouver Taxi Association

Second case of measles reported in the B.C. Interior

Case is connected to an earlier measles case in 100 Mile House

Most Read