LETTER: Canadian ‘speculators’ net benefit to B.C. economy

Recently, the B.C. Minister of Finance previewed two budget proposals ostensibly designed to address the cost of owning or renting residential property in British Columbia. The stated targets were Canadians officially resident in other provinces who own vacation homes in B.C., and “foreigners” who live abroad for most of the year whose properties in B.C. stand empty for most of the year. These proposals created a storm of protest from a wide range of stakeholders.

The stakeholders directly affected include: both resident and non-resident owners, people looking for affordable housing, realtors, tradesmen who build and renovate homes, and people providing a broad range of retail products and services. Directly or indirectly, we are all affected.

In my opinion, these proposals will not only fail to achieve their stated purposes, they are likely to have negative consequences that far outweigh whatever benefit was sought. The market is both dynamic and sophisticated, making it difficult to predict the outcomes of changes in government policy. However, here are some probably consequences:

It will discourage investment in new housing by both B.C. residents and those from neighbouring provinces; will make rental properties scarcer and more expensive; will have a negative impact on the local economy, including job losses in services and construction; will lower the revenue the governments will receive from income, sales and municipal taxation; and will exacerbate tensions between provinces caused by pre-existing conflicts over cross-border pipelines and other matters. It will dash the hopes and dreams of many people who in good faith decided to live, at least part-time, in B.C.

The rhetoric justifying these proposals paints a largely false picture of new residents to B.C. They are portrayed as “speculators” taking advantage of rising property values to “gouge” long-term residents. In reality, our temporary visitors from other provinces provide a net financial benefit to the provincial treasury. There are elements of nativism in that rhetoric similar to what is emerging in political discourse in the U.S. and parts of Europe.

It makes little sense to impose a solution designed to address Vancouver’s housing problems. The Comox Regional District is exluded despite having similar demographics to Parksville Qualicum Beach and the Okanagan. The main difference is the MLA for Comox is a member of the government party.

Dr. John Hogarth


Just Posted

Blue Tie Campaign set to tee off Aug. 25

Annual event is fundraiser for the Island Prostate Centre

Vancouver Island woman to attempt historic swim across Juan de Fuca Strait today

Ultra-marathon swimmer Susan Simmons to attempt to swim from Victoria to Port Angeles and back

Four people sent to hospital in crash near Qualicum Beach

Fire crews worked alongside paramedics: Dashwood fire dept.

Sisters share exhibit in Qualicum Beach

From gnomes and fairytales to trees and texture, but plenty of connections between pair

VIDEO: Jazz greats sound off in Parksville

Concert featured Phil Dwyer music academy faculty

Some of B.C.’s air quality levels worse than Jodhpur, India

Okanagan, northern B.C. seeing some of the worst air quality globally

Thousands to attend funeral service for officers killed in Fredericton shooting

Hundreds of officials marched in the parade, which included massed band, several police motorcycles

VIDEO: Ground crews keep a close eye on largest B.C. wildfire

Originally estimated to be 79,192 hectares, officials said more accurate mapping shows smaller size

Canadians believe in immigration but concerned about asylum seekers: study

Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada paid for study to understand Canadian attitudes

These are the highest-paid actresses of 2018

In its list released this week Forbes said all 10 earned a total of $186 million before tax

VIDEO: Fires break out in scrap piles at mill on Vancouver Island

Nanaimo firefighters got blazes under control in early morning hours Saturday at Harmac Pacific

Two hurt in car wreck on old Island Highway

Honda and Volkswagen crash at 10 p.m. Friday at highway intersection in Nanaimo

Authorities mull evacuation order for Zeballos

Smoke billowed from the steep hillsides of Zeballos on Friday evening, as… Continue reading

Most Read