LETTER: Bitumen upgrading a bad economic, environmental idea

Yvonne Zarowny (Alberta must refine bitumen before shipping it, Letters, Feb. 15) invites us to get involved in this debate. Having spent much of my career and all of this last week reviewing options for upgrading in Alberta, I’ll do just that, but briefly on the bitumen processing. The social justice issues raised by Yvonne need more space.

The balance between processed and unprocessed bitumen in an exporting country is based on economics and offshore refinery capabilities. Kinder Morgan’s shippers know there is a market for 800,000 barrels per day of diluted bitumen via the pipeline and the port of Vancouver, instead of using rail cars to other parts. While a market for some added synthetic crude could be developed, the economics are very sub-standard (four per cent return on a good day) and require government assistance to make them fly with investors. Which Canadian government is willing to say to its voters: we are shovelling more money to the “big, bad oil companies?”

Now let’s look at greenhouse gases for those who worry about possible catastrophic man-made climate change. Processing bitumen twice (upgrader and downstream refinery) has the unfortunate effect of markedly increasing life cycle GHG emissions through double processing. The Alberta government has set a cap of 100 mega-tonnes CO2 for oil sands production, and while there have been (and still are) great efforts to reduce CO2 footprint in the oil sands industry, to do as the writer suggests will take emissions well above the cap, and may require the Alberta producers to cut an enormous amount of bitumen production and likely cut production. Not a winner for Alberta or Canada.

These are all complex questions, but I applaud Ron Kyle (Canada runs on Alberta oil, not B.C. wine, Letters, Feb. 15) in his address to the economic issues. The spill issues are real, but already adequately addressed with world class tanker technology, shipping controls from the Burnaby terminal and clean up technology.

Len Flint

Qualicum Beach

Just Posted

Foul play not suspected in man’s death in Chemainus

Long attempt made to revive unidentified person on the dock

Parksville-area watchdogs say drivers getting message on cell use

Other distracted driving habits still a problem

Upgrade work on Dunsmuir Park underway

The Dunsmuir Community Park in Electoral Area H is being upgraded. A… Continue reading

Darts league looking for new teams and members

Darts season is almost here. It’s time to sharpen your shafts and… Continue reading

Mid-Vancouver Island air quality risk very high

Residents of the mid-Island area went to bed last night and awoke… Continue reading

Social media, digital photography allow millennials to flock to birdwatching

More young people are flocking to birdwatching than ever, aided by social media, digital photography

New B.C. Hydro electric car chargers launch on Vancouver Island

Fast-chargers to reduce ‘range anxiety’ for B.C. electric car drivers

‘Takes more courage to fail’: B.C. ultra-marathon swimmer reflects on cancelled try at record

Susan Simmons halted her swim from Victoria to Port Angeles and back because of hypothermia

Animals moved from B.C. Interior shelters to make way for pets displaced by wildfires

The Maple Ridge SPCA houses animals to make space for pets evacuated from B.C.’s burning interior.

$21.5 million medical pot plant to be built in B.C.

The facility is to be built in Princeton

Spokane man enlists 500,000+ box fans to blow wildfire smoke back to B.C.

Spokane man Caleb Moon says he’s had enough with smoky skies from B.C.’s forest fires blanketing his city

Feds agree to look at easing jury secrecy as part of review

At issue is a law that forbids jurors from talking about closed-door deliberations

Forest fuel work needed to slow wildfires, B.C. premier says

Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan joins John Horgan for tour

Liberals unveil poverty plan with lofty goals, but no new spending

Government’s goal is to lift 2.1 million people out of poverty by 2030

Most Read