LETTER: Bitumen upgrading a bad economic, environmental idea

Yvonne Zarowny (Alberta must refine bitumen before shipping it, Letters, Feb. 15) invites us to get involved in this debate. Having spent much of my career and all of this last week reviewing options for upgrading in Alberta, I’ll do just that, but briefly on the bitumen processing. The social justice issues raised by Yvonne need more space.

The balance between processed and unprocessed bitumen in an exporting country is based on economics and offshore refinery capabilities. Kinder Morgan’s shippers know there is a market for 800,000 barrels per day of diluted bitumen via the pipeline and the port of Vancouver, instead of using rail cars to other parts. While a market for some added synthetic crude could be developed, the economics are very sub-standard (four per cent return on a good day) and require government assistance to make them fly with investors. Which Canadian government is willing to say to its voters: we are shovelling more money to the “big, bad oil companies?”

Now let’s look at greenhouse gases for those who worry about possible catastrophic man-made climate change. Processing bitumen twice (upgrader and downstream refinery) has the unfortunate effect of markedly increasing life cycle GHG emissions through double processing. The Alberta government has set a cap of 100 mega-tonnes CO2 for oil sands production, and while there have been (and still are) great efforts to reduce CO2 footprint in the oil sands industry, to do as the writer suggests will take emissions well above the cap, and may require the Alberta producers to cut an enormous amount of bitumen production and likely cut production. Not a winner for Alberta or Canada.

These are all complex questions, but I applaud Ron Kyle (Canada runs on Alberta oil, not B.C. wine, Letters, Feb. 15) in his address to the economic issues. The spill issues are real, but already adequately addressed with world class tanker technology, shipping controls from the Burnaby terminal and clean up technology.

Len Flint

Qualicum Beach

Just Posted

Deep Bay artist creates abstract sculptures using cement

Birgit Piskor’s artist journey has blossomed from gardener to sculpture

Fill the fire engines in District 69 for 2018

Firefighters set to conduct annual food and toy drive

Grandmothers to Grandmothers host annual Christmas Extravaganza

Crafts, baked goods, knitting and many more homemade treasures available at fundraiser

Gridiron Whalers go marching past Saints

Ballenas defence holds off surging Langley to secure spot in playoff quarterfinals

Who wants to have coffee with Parksville’s mayor?

Coffee with Ed Mayne will take place Thursdays, starting Nov. 15

VIDEO: Marvel Comics’ Stan Lee dies

Marvel co-creator was well-known for making cameo appearances in superhero movies

Most fatal overdose victims did not have recent police contact: Stats Canada

11 per cent of those who fatally overdosed in B.C. had four or more contacts with the police

Tragic conclusion to search for overdue hiker west of Campbell River

An overdue hiker was found deceased on the shore of Lower Campbell… Continue reading

Who was Chris Bloomfield, the Mill Bay man shot by police?

A troubled man with a voracious appetite for illicit drugs and a non-conventional lifestyle

Calgarians head to the polls to declare ‘yea’ or ‘nay’ on Winter Games

The question “are you for or are you against hosting the 2026 Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games?” was to be posed to them Tuesday in a plebiscite to help determine whether the city should move ahead with a bid.

Heir’s big birthday: 70 candles lined up for Prince Charles

Prince Charles turns 70 Wednesday, Nov. 14, 2018, still serving in the heir to the throne role he has filled since he was a young child.

Vancouver Island duo honoured for raising $1 million for MS

Darcie and Kevin James hail from Cobble Hill

Trudeau lays down challenge to companies in bid to boost trade with Asia

“Building the relationships, building the connections, building the facility and also changing mindsets — getting Canadian companies to see the opportunities we have around the world to partner and invest.”

CNN sues Trump, demanding return of Acosta to White House

CNN is asking for an immediate restraining order to return Acosta to the White House.

Most Read