Mining for open minds

Jonathan McCully was a lukewarm supporter of a Colonial Union. As a contributor to the Halifax Morning Chronicle, the major Liberal newspaper in Nova Scotia at the time, he expressed his views strongly and frequently.

In 1864 one of his former students, Sir Charles Tupper, named both Liberal and Conservative delegates to represent the province in Charlottetown. At that conference, McCully was converted from his praising of the notion of a colonial union to that of Confederation.

As the province’s Solicitor General, railway commissioner and editorial contributor at the Chronicle, McCully was in a position to have his voice heard. After his conversion, Joseph Howe took control of the Chronicle and in 1865 McCully was fired as the newspaper swung over to an anti-confederation stance.

McCully promptly bought the Morning Journal and Commercial Advertiser and began two years of selling confederation to readers. As a “Father of Confederation” he was a delegate to the conference of 1867. His career demonstrates the influence of political journalism on confederation, with his editorials contributing to a shift in public opinion in favour of confederation.

Had McCully been a politician in today’s world, it’s likely he would have been branded a “flip-flopper” by the media and his arguments would have lost weight. Keeping an open mind allowed those making the arguments for and against confederation to choose the best path, and get the best terms for citizens.

Would we be as open-minded today?

With the winds of political change blowing through B.C., The U.S.A. and Great Britain, it appears that those that are motivated to vote have little appetite for intellectual arguments. They’re more inclined to feed on a steady diet of sound bites — most limited to 140 characters — than proposing and discussing ideas and philosophies. Watching Canadian Parliamentary debates does nothing to reinforce the belief that we are somehow above the rest.

It appears today that we vote for, or against party leaders, rather than ideology.

In this country at various government levels, there have been epic debates surrounding Medicare, the Canadian Pension Plan and free trade. They captivated and engaged the public, and set the tone for our future. Now, it seems it’s more about the party leader and how he or she has been branded or labelled.

As we celebrate 150 years of Confederation, let’s endeavour to elevate the level of discussion and engagement to that which started us on this journey as a nation.

— Parksville Qualicum Beach News

Just Posted

RDN seeks guidance for Area F projects

Five-year Project Plan to be updated

UPDATED: Remains of two people found in Ucluelet

Officials have not said whether or not the remains belong to Ryan Daley or Dan Archbald

B.C. turns up the heat

Environment Canada has issued a special weather statement for most the province due to high temperatures

RDN to create conceptual designs for fire halls

Committee endorses standardization design of buildings

UPDATE: Oceanside RCMP say teen has been located

Police asked for public assistance last week while looking for Isaiah Taylor

VIDEO: Seaside Cruizers Show and Shine in Parksville Qualicum Beach

Hot rods, American muscle and more featured June 15-17

Coastal Community expands wealth services presence in Qualicum Beach

New offices are located in heart of Qualicum Beach’s business district

Cheers erupt as Federal Court judge approves historic gay purge settlement

Gay military veterans said they were interrogated, harassed and spied on because of their sexuality

Helping B.C.’s helpers cope

The MRT has helped almost 7,000 first responders and street workers in 57 communities in B.C.

Border officials argue B.C. man’s Facebook posts threat to Canada’s security

A B.C. Supreme Court judge acquitted Othman Hamdan of terrorism charges last September

Reena Virk’s mother has died

Both of Virk’s parents became activists against bullying in wake of daughter’s death

Search for capsized fishers near Tofino enters fourth day

“There’s a lot of shock in the community in terms of how we could end up at this place.”

B.C. announces $75M to help friends, family care for seniors at home

Funding will go towards respite care and adult day programs

Timely tide attracts another pod of orcas to Victoria

The pod left the harbour about 30 minutes later

Most Read