Trails, not rails are the answer

Re: ‘B.C. Gov’t to fund assessment of E&N rail line’ (PQB News, Jan. 6)

The Jan. 10 letter by resident Tim Benesh echoes my sentiment favouring trails over rails in the E&N line.

News stories about the rail repairs to the Churchill, Man., rail line should give Vancouver Island residents cause for concern.

In that case, it was initially claimed repairs to a small segment of the 280-kilometre rail line would cost $43 million but, in the recent sale announcement, was said to be $74 million.

Compare that amount to the $15 million previously claimed by the ICF for bringing the 220-kilometre Victoria-to-Courtenay line into service, and the math just doesn’t add up.

The announced E&N assessment, if conducted by a responsible engineering consultant, would most likely decline to offer any assurances of safety and reliability of roadbed, trestle and bridge assets, without major investment far exceeding those on flatland Manitoba. I personally doubt that another federal $74 million would be adequate to make the E&N rail line operable.

Alternately, trails that were portions of former railways elsewhere in Canada, are used for recreation and tourism and have spawned businesses along the route, including bike rentals, B&Bs, and coffee shops.

The trail goes through the centre of several towns, providing a range of local services to trail travellers.

An ICF trail through Qualicum Beach would provide exactly this range of services for hikers and bikers. It would also be so much safer that bicycle travel along the old Island Highway.

The foolishness about reviving rail service from Victoria to Courtenay should end. Put this corridor to some uses that would benefit local communities.

Steve Smith

Qualicum Beach

Just Posted

Parksville council eyes city boundary expansion

More industrial land a key motivator in notice of motion

2019 Federal election: Courtenay-Alberni candidates address seniors issues

“What are your party’s plans to ease the stress realized by seniors on fixed incomes?”

Errington Hall gears up for another season

Family-friendly venue has a variety of acts booked for 2019-20

WATCH: Jordan now a key member on staff at Parksville business

Disability Awareness Month celebrated around province

RDN wants to play role in Ballenas track upgrade

Bringing dilapidated facility up to standard could cost close to $1M

VIDEO: “How dare you?” Greta Thunberg addresses UN climate summit

‘We are in the beginning of a mass extinction and yet all you can talk about is money.’

Pettersson has 4 points as Canucks dump Ottawa 6-4

Vancouver wins NHL pre-season tilt in Abbotsford

British man returns to Yukon to tipple his own toe in long-running tradition

So-called sourtoe cocktail is a shot of whisky with a mummified human toe in it

Poll suggests Canadians concerned about fake news, but struggle to spot it

56 per cent of respondents admitted to reading or sharing inaccurate news

Province announces $3.5 million in funding for community solutions to overdose crisis

Grants up to $50,000 will be available for municipalities working with a regional health authority

Conservatives’ plan to ease mortgage stress-test rules may raise debt and prices

Andrew Scheer vows to loosen rules around stress test and remove it altogether for mortgage renewals

B.C. mom urges patience after rude comments while out with toddlers

People asked to be better and to help each other

U.S. wrestler says viral speeding ticket video was staged

WWE wrestler Lacey Evans says she does not condone disrespecting law enforcement officers

‘Own a piece of history’: Beachcombers location Molly’s Reach up for sale

‘This is one of B.C.’s most photographed buildings’

Most Read